Allday Pizza: Tarrytown

Nora a month ago

We ordered the sampler pie and the Caesar salad. Of the different flavors, the tomato slice was my least favorite, as it lacked flavor and didn’t stand out to me 4/10. The stracciatella was definitely my favorite and easily a 9/10, while the pickle slice was unique and surprisingly good—I’d give it a 7.5/10. The atmosphere was lively, and they have outdoor seating. Also, it is definitely on the pricier side. We paid about $60 for one sampler pie and a Caesar salad, without any drinks, which felt expensive for the portion size. Overall, we had a good experience and would come back to try more items from the menu, but be prepared for higher prices.

Ramin 2 months ago

We visited All Day Pizza and tried the pepperoni pizza, the Sweet Sausage pizza, and a salad. The atmosphere was one of the best parts of the experience. The place has a cool, relaxed vibe with both indoor and outdoor seating, making it a nice spot to hang out with friends or enjoy a casual meal. The overall setup and atmosphere were inviting and enjoyable. The salad was very good—fresh, flavorful, and probably the highlight of our meal. The pizzas, however, were average overall. We specifically asked for no honey on the Sweet Sausage pizza, but it was still served with honey drizzled on top. Unfortunately, we did not enjoy the combination, and the pizza was not tasty to us. The pepperoni pizza was better compared to the Sweet Sausage pizza. It was not bad, but it was also not particularly memorable. They do offer several creative and unusual pizza options, including a pickle pizza, so the menu is definitely more interesting and different than a typical pizza place. Overall, the atmosphere and salad were great, but the pizzas did not fully meet our expectations—especially the Sweet Sausage pizza and the fact that our request to leave off the honey was missed.

Nij Chawla 2 months ago

Cute atmosphere to sit outside. It’s neighbor Flo not so. Dry vibe inside. No music. Dull lightning. Could use mood lighting. Let’s come to food! One of the best if not the best crust in Austin. Insane NY style pizza in Austin! Legendary - as good as it gets • Sweet sausage pizza • The crust here is out of this world. Juicy yet can hold in one hand NY style. Crunchy and moist Loved it - order every time • Spicy Margharita Not bad - could do again maybe • Pepp and Pepp - too much Pepp. And v salty Avoid • Cacio de peppe pizza - no taste. Zero flavor • Pickle pizza

Sharon Roell 4 months ago

With lines out the door, we arrived for an early (6:30pm) dinner and already had about 20 parties ahead in queue. We had high expectations and while quite pricey the portions were large and Allday definitely did not disappoint. The pizza was delicious - perfectly crispy thin crust but with a good bite and great flavor. We picked sweet sausage, spicy margherita and pickle of course. My family loved them all but I thought the sweet sausage was just a little heavy on the honey and found it a bit off-putting. The Caesar salad was about the best I’ve ever had with the most tender yet crispy lettuce and deliciously flavorful but light dressing - incredible! Finally, the olive oil cake was exactly as expected - perfectly crunchy consistency, with the perfect taste of lemon and olive oil. So, so good.

Surya Chilakapati 5 months ago

Best pizza in Austin! And Best location out of the All day pizzas. Connected to Flo’s bottles shop it’s such a vibe for friends or date night! Highly recommend this spot! Our favorites were : Stracciatella & Spicy Margherita get those! But for sure the stracciatella if you are going to order a whole pie. But I would get different slices if it’s your first time.